Chapter 2 - THE MAN IN THE PHOTOGRAPH
I called my father first. He didn't answer. I called Ben and asked him to check the downstairs hallway, the building manager's office, the pharmacy, anywhere Dad might have gone on his own. Ben's voice trembled through the phone.
“His wallet's here, Em. His medicine, too. He wouldn't go anywhere without his medicine.”
I showed the message to Luca. Within a minute he was on the phone to the police, explaining that a man with limited mobility might have been taken against his will. He didn't ask me to trust one of his private drivers. He asked where my father had last been seen and whether Ben had someone with him. It was the first time I understood what real help looked like: not promises, but questions that narrowed a terrible uncertainty.
At three in the morning, we drove to my neighborhood in two cars. I sat beside Nora, who had returned after Luca called her. Ben met us outside the apartment wearing sweatpants and his old high school soccer jacket. He looked at Luca as though the man were a thunderstorm that had walked out of the sky.
“Why is he here?” Ben asked.
“Because someone may be using Dad to scare me,” I said. “And because I asked for help.”
Inside, the apartment smelled of burnt toast. Dad's cup sat on the kitchen table, still half full. His newspaper lay open to the crossword page, where he'd completed only three answers. The empty place beside his chair made my chest hurt in a way I couldn't explain.
The police took the threatening message and security footage from the building's entrance. It showed a dark sedan. My father stepped toward it slowly, leaning on a cane instead of his walker. A woman got out, spoke to him, and offered an arm. He did not look frightened. After a moment, he climbed into the back seat.
“Do you recognize her?” the detective asked.
“No,” I said.
Ben leaned close to the screen. “Wait. She came here last month. She said she was from an insurance company.”
“What did she want?”
“She asked about Dad's old work records. He told her he was retired. She left a card, but he threw it out.”
Luca asked me whether my father kept any old photographs. I led him into the narrow bedroom where Dad still had a toolbox beneath the bed. The smell of oil was faint but familiar. In its bottom drawer was a weathered envelope containing employment records from his last year with a company called Halcyon Lift Services. The photograph Mrs. Caruso had shown me matched one in the folder.
The man beside Dad was named Thomas Kells.
I remembered the name from childhood, though not from a story anyone had told directly. At sixteen, I once heard Dad arguing with another mechanic in our garage. The man had said Thomas couldn't be brought back. Dad replied that the problem wasn't bringing him back; it was making somebody admit why he'd died.
When I told Luca, his face changed.
“Thomas Kells,” he repeated. “He was the engineer who inspected the elevators at the old Harbor Exchange building.”
“The building your company bought?” Nora asked.
“Five years ago. Before I owned it, there was an accident in a freight shaft. Two workers died.”
I stared at him. “One of them was Thomas?”
“Yes.”
The bedroom felt suddenly smaller. My father had suffered his stroke two years ago after months of stress over some lawsuit he refused to discuss. I'd thought his silence came from pride. Maybe it was fear.
The detective requested the Halcyon files, while Nora checked the civil records. The report of Thomas's death had blamed equipment failure and human error. My father's name appeared as a dissenting inspector: he had refused to certify the lift before the accident. Six months later, the dissent had been removed from an amended report.
“Someone changed the record,” Nora said.
Luca stared at the screen. “And the company that submitted the amendment was Bellini Industrial Holdings.”
Vanessa's father's business.
It wasn't proof that Vanessa had arranged tonight's danger. It was worse in a different way. It made what I'd heard in the foyer part of a pattern that stretched back years and ended in dead men.
While the detective traced the car, my brother opened the refrigerator and stared at its contents as though he expected Dad to be waiting behind the milk. There was a container of stew I'd made Sunday and three slices of bread wrapped in wax paper. He took out the stew and set it on the counter without heating it.
“Dad always complains when we waste food,” Ben said.
“We're not wasting it.”
“He'll come back and complain we left the lights on.”
“Yes.”
I needed to believe that as much as he did.
Ben sat at the table. His phone showed half a dozen calls he'd made to people from Dad's old crew. Most had retired; one had moved to Arizona. A mechanic named Felix had answered and said our father sometimes attended an informal breakfast at a diner near the train station. Ben called the diner. The waitress there remembered Dad from years ago but hadn't seen him that morning.
“I feel useless,” Ben admitted. “I know how to read a wiring diagram. I can't even tell whether somebody tricked our dad into a car.”
I put my hand on his shoulder. “You knew about the insurance woman. You found the security camera. That's not useless.”
He looked at Luca, who was speaking to Nora in the living room. “Do you trust him?”
I wanted to say yes. Instead I told the truth. “I trust what I've seen him do tonight. I don't know enough about the rest.”
Ben nodded slowly. “That's probably smarter.”
A little later we found an appointment card beneath Dad's notebook. It had a date from three weeks earlier and the name of a speech therapist we'd never met. The clinic confirmed Dad had not attended an appointment there. Someone had requested his medical history using information from an old insurance record. The clinic had declined to release it without authorization. We gave the card to Ruiz, adding it to the timeline.
The discovery unsettled me because it suggested the night wasn't improvised. Somebody had been asking about Dad long before I pressed the elevator stop. Maybe the old records had become important again when the Bellini partnership advanced. Maybe my father's knowledge had made him dangerous to someone. I couldn't yet know which explanation was true.
I remembered the last time Mom was in the hospital. Dad would bring a notebook to each visit, writing down every unfamiliar word so he could ask the nurses to explain it. He didn't pretend to understand things he didn't. He asked questions until he did. That was how he'd approached machines, too. For him, questions weren't defiance. They were the beginning of responsibility.
I took the half-finished crossword from the kitchen table and folded it into my coat pocket. Wherever he was, I wanted him to have something familiar when we found him.
At dawn, the detective called with a lead. Traffic cameras had followed the sedan into an industrial district near the river, where it entered a fenced medical transport depot. An officer was on the way. I wanted to go immediately. Luca offered to come, but the detective asked us to stay clear until they knew who was inside.
Waiting is a kind of punishment. Ben paced between the kitchen and the window. Nora made calls to hospitals. Luca sat with his phone face up on the table, responding to every update as though it carried the weight of a verdict. I made coffee nobody drank.
At eight-thirty, the detective called again. The depot was empty. A security guard said the sedan had left an hour earlier. He also said a man resembling Dad had been helped into a white medical van. The van's destination was listed as Westbrook Rehabilitation Center, forty miles outside Chicago.
“That's not his clinic,” I said.
The detective was already contacting Westbrook. They had no current patient by my father's name. But the transport manifest used the initials H.R. and a false birth date.
Dad's name was Harold Reed.
I couldn't sit still any longer. I asked the detective for permission to meet officers at the facility. She said they would call when the location was safe. I protested; she reminded me that arriving in a panic could make it harder to help. I hated that she was right.
By noon, they found Dad in a private room at an assisted-care facility adjoining Westbrook. He had not been physically harmed. The staff believed he was there voluntarily under a temporary respite-care agreement. The paperwork bore a signature that looked like mine.
I had signed nothing.
When I saw him, he gripped my hand and tried to speak. His stroke had left some words slow, especially when he was upset. His eyes shone with rage.
“Woman,” he managed. “Said... you... trouble.”
“I'm okay, Dad.”
He shook his head. “She... had... Thomas.”
“Thomas is dead,” I said.
Dad squeezed my hand hard enough to hurt. He reached for the little notebook he used during speech therapy and wrote, one shaky word at a time:
THOMAS KEPT A COPY.
“What copy?”
He turned the page, but his hand faltered. I waited. After a minute, he wrote:
THE ELEVATOR WASN'T THE FIRST TRAP.
A nurse came to check his blood pressure. Luca stepped into the corridor to speak with the detective. I stayed beside Dad until his breathing steadied. He looked at me with a sorrow I remembered from the day my mother died, when he'd held a broken man together because his children needed him.
“I'm not leaving you again,” I told him.
He lifted his hand and pointed to my phone. The screen showed a missed call from an unknown number. Then it rang again.
I answered. A woman's voice said, “If you want the file that proves who killed Thomas Kells, come to the old Harbor Exchange alone. Leave the Morettis out of it.”
“Who are you?” I demanded.
“Someone your father should have listened to five years ago.”
The call ended. A second later a photograph arrived: my father and Thomas standing in the same elevator shaft, but this time a third person stood between them. He wore a hard hat and held a clipboard.
I recognized his face from the photographs in Luca's study.
May you like
It was Luca's father, Giovanni Moretti.
He had been dead for four years.
